windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f9 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

So last week ATI was kind enough to send me over their new Catalyst Drivers, version 8.12, for testing, not only does it include several improvements but also the new AVIVO Video Converter Program that utilizes the ATI Graphics Chip for faster encoding of videos. This version isn’t due out until the 10th, but I’ve been hard at it testing the performance in several games for comparison between version 8.11 and version 8.12.

So read on to learn what I learned, I tested with many games including FarCry2, Crysis, Crysis Warhead, Call of Duty World at War, Fallout3 and Spiderman Web of Shadows as well…

Here’s a quick overview of the new release:

Highlights of the ATI Catalyst™ 8.12 Windows driver release include:

New Features:

ATI Stream support:

*With the release of ATI Catalyst 8.12 users can unlock the potential of accelerated applications enabling ATI Stream technology for millions of ATI Radeon™ graphics processors worldwide

*ATI Stream harnesses the tremendous processing power of the graphics processing unit (GPU) for high-performance, data-intensive computations over a wide range of scientific, business and consumer applications.

*ATI Stream enables the hundreds of parallel cores inside AMD graphics processors to accelerate general purpose applications.  These capabilities will allow ATI Stream-enabled programs, for a variety of different tasks and from a growing number of software vendors, to operate with optimized performance or with new functionality.

*The CAL (Compute Abstraction Layer) is now include in the Catalyst driver package. CAL is the enabling component for ATI Stream

ATI Stream application:  ATI Avivo Video Converter

* Using ATI Stream technology, owners of ATI Radeon™ HD 4800 Series and ATI Radeon™ HD 4600 Series of graphics cards can take advantage of this video conversion tool (found in Catalyst Control Center Basic View) to achieve incredible performance levels in video transcoding.

ATI Catalyst Control Center – Noise reduction for progressive video content:

* This release of Catalyst™ introduces a new advanced video quality control:  Noise Reduction for progressive video content, which removes ghosting artifacts while preserving details of the original video.  The slider control can be found in the All Settings page of the Avivo Video tab found in the Catalyst Control Center.  

Performance improvements:

Catalyst 8.12 Preliminary Performance Notes

Crysis + 2-7%
Crysis Warhead + 2-3%
Devil May Cry 4  + 1-6%
Far Cry 2
+ noAA scores are fixed for Crossfire configs; this is worth +20% on slower cards, and as much as 70% on faster ones
+ 5-10% gains when AA is enabled

FEAR + 2-6%
Left 4 Dead + 2-4%
Lost Planet Colonies + 3-10%, mostly in Area 2
Prey + 2-5%
STALKER Clear Sky + 5-10%, primarily on Crossfire configurations

————————

Now onto my part of all of this….

First up the basics of  my system:

Intel C2Q6600 @ 2531Mhz

4gigs of OCZ Fatal1ty DDR2 memory @ 5-4-4-15

Diamond Radeon 4870 1gig

Vista Ultimate x64

of course I’ve got hard drives in there and DVDRW drives as well, but you don’t need the particulars of those.

Windows Vista is fully patched and all games have the most recent patches on them.

Ok, for most games I used FRAPS to record the framerates and then averaged them out, I played the same section three times over to try and get some semblance of equality in testing.

For some games I used the built in benchmarks, like FarCry2, Crysis and Crysis Warhead.

First up we’ll check out SiSoft Sandra 2009 Video Rendering Benchmark using DX10.1

Benchmark the graphics performance of the video adapters.

The test involves the generation of Mandelbrot Set fractals that are used to realistically describe and generate natural objects such as mountains or clouds. Such instructions are used for audio and video encoding and decoding, games and other applications where the same operation needs to be applied to large amount of data

Float Shaders (Pixels/s) – higher results are better, i.e. better single (32-bit) floating-point performance.

Double Shaders (Pixels/s) – higher results are better, i.e. better double (64-bit) floating-point performance.

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252fsandra graph thumb 1 ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

We can see here that actually version 8.12 scored a bit lower than the 8.11 drivers…

Next, I figured why not run 3dMark06:

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f3dmark06 thumb 1 ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

Very, slight increase, nothing to get excited about at all…

Now we have Far Cry 2:

Settings DX9:

Demo(Ranch Small), 1680×1050 (59Hz), D3D9, Fixed Time Step(No), Disable Artificial Intelligence(No), Full Screen, Anti-Aliasing(2x), VSync(No), Overall Quality(Optimal), Vegetation(Very High), Shading(Very High), Terrain(Very High), Geometry(Very High), Post FX(High), Texture(Very High), Shadow(Very High), Ambient(High), Hdr(Yes), Bloom(Yes), Fire(Very High), Physics(Very High), RealTrees(Very High)

Setting DX10:

Demo(Ranch Small), 1680×1050 (59Hz), D3D10, Fixed Time Step(No), Disable Artificial Intelligence(No), Full Screen, Anti-Aliasing(2x), VSync(No), Overall Quality(Optimal), Vegetation(Very High), Shading(Very High), Terrain(Very High), Geometry(Very High), Post FX(High), Texture(Very High), Shadow(Very High), Ambient(High), Hdr(Yes), Bloom(Yes), Fire(Very High), Physics(Very High), RealTrees(Very High)

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252ffarcry2 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

We see a very small increase when moving to the new driver version on the average.

Now I recently got Spiderman Web of Shadows for review, and I figured I could bench it while trying it out.

There’s really no settings for Spiderman at all though.

1680×1050 Resolution

Shadows Enabled

Particle Effects Enabled

Special Effects Enabled

V-Sync Disabled

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252fspiderman thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

We see a large jump in frame rates when going from the 8.11 to the 8.12 drivers with Spiderman. With Spiderman it’s hard to make the game exactly the same every time you play it as things constantly change, I tried to do everything exactly the same each time I ran though it.

Next up is Crysis:

1680×1050 – High Settings – 2X AA

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252fcrysis thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

We see a slight increase but not much really here.

Now we have Crysis Warhead:

1680×1050 – Gamer Mode – 2X AA

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252fcrysis warhead thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

Not much of a real difference at all here either.

Next up we’ve got Call of Duty World at War, I used FRAPS of course and I played from the Beach to the Beach Landing 3 times each.. fun-fun

1680×1050 Resolution
Aspect Ratio – Auto
4x AA
Sync Every Frame – No
Specular Map -Yes
Ocean Simulation – Yes
Dynamic Foliage – Yes
Bullet Impacts – Yes
Number of Corpses – Medium
Texture Filtering – Automatic
Texture Quality – Automatic

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252fcod ww thumb 2 ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

Here we see the averages do go up using the new 8.12 drivers, not sure what’s up with the minimum dropping like that though, I tried to do the exact same thing each time, but I may have done something a bit differently. Still though what we want to look at is the Averages, and they do go up quite a bit using the new Catalyst drivers.

Finally I’ve got Fallout 3

1680×1050 16:10 Widescreen Resolution
4X AA
15X AF
HDR is on
Vertical Sync is on
Texture Quality – high
Radial Blur Quality – high
Depth of Field is on
Transparency Multisampling is on
Decal Cap 10

Water, everything is set On and High
Shadows, everything is High and Max
View Distance, everything is Max
Distance LOD, evertinhg is Max

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252ffallout3 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

We see a big difference here between the versions of the drivers, pushing the average way up

Of course the most important thing here is this new version of the Catalyst Drivers is the Video Converter, and honestly it’s hit and miss with it, sure it’s fast, very fast to convert movies. Only problem is though I ran into problems with it, sometimes my video would be converted with no sound, sometimes there would be sound but no picture and other times it would be all scrambled, the video I mean would be.

What I did was try several things, .AVI to .MPEG, .AVI to .WMV and .WMV to .MPEG.

What I wanted to do was give you some nice graphs with times and all that, but I can’t because it truly didn’t work correctly every time for me, so that would be wrong to give you results based on those.

Originally I used three different video converting programs and was going to compare their times to AVIVO times, sure it’s fast, like going from  20+ minutes to convert a 615mb WMV file to MPEG using Daniusoft Convertor to doing the same thing in under 5 minutes using Avivo Video Converter. That worked perfectly though, so great.

Next I tried converting a 350mb .AVI file to .WMV, using Arcosft Media Convertor and it took a little over 7 minutes, while using Avivo it took under one minute but I had audio and no video.

Yes, ok it’s new, so there’s bound to be bugs and I’m sure we’ll be seeing a hotfix for it soon for any of the problems, but still it would be nice if it worked somewhat.

Anyway, here’s some screenshots for you of how the whole process looks and works, you’ve got to be in Basic Mode of Catalyst Control Center though to access the Avivo Program.

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f1 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f2 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

 windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f3 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f4 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f5 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysiswindowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f6 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f7 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis windowslivewriteraticatalyst812performanceanalysis 1252f8 thumb ATI Catalyst 8.12 Performance Analysis

Overall the drivers themselves do give you a bit of a performance gain, and the Avivo is a very cool feature, but I would like to see it have options for changing sizes, bitrates etc for the end result videos. Yes there are choices for Sony PSP and iPod Video so they should be the correct size, but I would still like to have full control over the final output.

 

 

 

 

 

This driver will be posted live on AMD.COM December 10th, 2008